UMBC ebiquity
Journal requires authors to include Wikipedia article with submissions

Journal requires authors to include Wikipedia article with submissions

Tim Finin, 11:34pm 18 December 2008

Scientific journals are undergoing rapid evolution as they adapt to the Web and various forms of social media. As reported by Nature (Publish in Wikipedia or perish) and in ReadWriteWeb, the journal RNA Biology is experimenting with a connection to Wikipedia. Articles submitted for publication about new RNA molecules must also include a draft Wikipedia page that summarizes the work. The journal will then peer review the page before publishing it in Wikipedia.

Here are the guidelines from the RNA Biology site:

“To be eligible for publication the Supplementary Material must contain: (1) a link to a Wikipedia article preferably in a User’s space. Upon acceptance this can easily be moved into Wikipedia itself together with a reference to the published article.

At least one stub article (essentially an extended abstract) for the paper should be added to either an author’s userspace at Wikipedia (preferred route) or added directly to the main Wikipedia space (be sure to add literature references to avoid speedy deletion). This article will be reviewed alongside the manuscript and may require revision before acceptance. Upon acceptance the former articles can easily be exported to the main Wikipedia space. See below for guidelines on how to do this. Existing articles can be updated in accordance with the latest published results.”

This is definitely an interesting and forward looking idea. Yet, I can not help having the cynical thought that it’s also a great way for the journal to boost it’s page rank.

Related posts:

  1. What makes a Wikipedia article good?
  2. Eigenfactor.org measures and visualizes journal impact
  3. On Wikipedia’s article on the Virginia Tech Massacre
  4. On evaluating the credibility of Wikipedia articles
  5. Journal of Web Semantics maintains high impact factor

2 Responses to “Journal requires authors to include Wikipedia article with submissions”

  1. Pat Says:

    Wikipedia articles can’t pass on pagerank, all of their links are rel=”nofollow”.

    Having each author write an entry is an interesting way to increasing the visibility of the journal and its articles though.

  2. Tim Finin Says:

    Hey — I didn’t realize that all wikipedia external links had a rel=nofollow attribute. Or, if I did, I’ve forgotten that fact (this is quite likely, anymore. sigh.)