UMBC ebiquity
New Yorker on voting systems and fair elections

New Yorker on voting systems and fair elections

Tim Finin, 12:11pm 25 July 2010

votingThis week’s New Yorker magazine has an article by Anthony Gottlieb on different voting systems, including range voting.

WIN OR LOSE: No voting system is flawless. But some are less democratic than others. Can theorists engineer a better way to elect candidates?

The article provides an interesting introduction to some of the voting systems that have been developed and used over the centuries and the advantages and vulnerabilities. There’s no mention of Scantegrity or security or the general issue of verifiability, however.

It’s actually in the Book’s section, so I guess it is ostensibly a review of a new book “Numbers Rule: The Vexing Mathematics of Democracy, from Plato to the Present” by journalist and mathematician George Szpiro.

The article also mentions a book by William Poundstone, “Gaming the Vote: Why Elections Aren’t Fair (and What We Can Do About It)” which is a steal on amazon for $5.00. Such a steal that I ordered two last week, one for me and one to share. Poundstone, btw, has written some good popular books on a wide range of topics (e.g., game theory, technical interviewing techniques, etc). I’ve read quite a few and both enjoyed them and learned things. According to Wikipedia, he is a cousin of comedian Paula Poundstone!

Related posts:

  1. XKCD on elections and voting
  2. 2007 Collegiate Voting Systems Competition
  3. Can range voting save us from politicians?
  4. How the Web Was Won, an oral history of the Internet in Vanity Fair
  5. Takoma Park uses Scantegrity voter verifiable voting system

3 Responses to “New Yorker on voting systems and fair elections”

  1. L Bellier Says:

    I can’t wait for this!
    After the movie from Micheal Moore on the automated calculators for votes (MUST SEE), i really think it’s the best way to go. Start by checking the viability of the machines that count votes and make sure it is not subjective!

    Great post, can’t wait for updates,

    L. Bellier
    reader of Ebiquity
    proud RSS reader of the tech section!

  2. Zak Show Says:

    I think William Poundstone book is a great resource to get information about the election science, I already read some pages of his 338 pages but I still have to check more about this. Do you know other interesting reads by W.P?

  3. L. Bellier Says:

    Fortune’s Formula is one good book.

    I only read a few. I liked alot BigSecret & BiggerSecrets which i read back in 95.
    But of that subject…sorry,

    L. Bellier
    reader of Ebiquity
    proud RSS reader of the tech section!